Understanding Vermont’s Legal Justice System Amid Rising Crime Rates

As Vermont faces an increase in crime rates, many residents are left wondering how the state’s justice system functions, who is accountable for enforcing laws, and what role the public can play in ensuring fair and effective governance. This article provides an overview of Vermont’s legal justice system, highlighting the responsibilities of law enforcement, prosecutors, judges, and the public’s role in holding officials accountable.

A Decentralized System with Local Authority

Vermont’s legal system operates with a decentralized structure, meaning much of the authority lies at the county level rather than with a centralized state agency. Law enforcement, prosecution, judicial oversight, and corrections are all handled with a mix of state and local governance.

Law Enforcement and Prosecution

Law enforcement responsibilities in Vermont are divided among:

Vermont State Police, which provide law enforcement in rural areas and towns without local departments.
Local and municipal police departments, which enforce laws within their respective cities and towns.
Sheriff’s departments, which primarily manage court security, prisoner transport, and some law enforcement duties in contracted communities.

Prosecution of crimes is handled at the county level by State’s Attorneys, who are elected officials responsible for charging and prosecuting crimes. This decentralized structure means that prosecution policies can vary from county to county, depending on the discretion of the elected State’s Attorney.

The Vermont Attorney General oversees legal matters at the state level and handles appeals and significant legal cases, but much of the day-to-day prosecution is left to individual counties.

The Judicial System: Appointment and Retention of Judges

Vermont’s court system consists of several tiers:

The Vermont Supreme Court is the highest appellate court, overseeing major legal disputes and ensuring that laws are applied consistently.
The Superior Court system, divided into different divisions (criminal, civil, family, probate, and environmental), handles most legal proceedings.
The Judicial Bureau handles minor offenses such as traffic violations.

Unlike elected prosecutors, Vermont’s judges are appointed by the governor but must undergo periodic review and approval by the legislature. Judges serve six-year terms, after which they must go through the judicial retention process.

This process is overseen by the Judicial Retention Committee, a group composed of members of the Vermont General Assembly. The committee evaluates judges based on their performance, taking into account public feedback and legal professionals’ opinions. Their recommendations are then brought to the full legislature, which votes on whether a judge should be retained. A judge must receive a majority vote from the legislature to continue serving.

Current Judges Up for Retention

First	Last	Type	Swearing In Date	Next Retention Date
Thomas	Zonay	Chief Superior Court Judge	03/01/07	03/31/25
H. Dickson	Corbett	Superior Court Judge	05/22/23	03/31/25
Kevin	Griffin	Superior Court Judge	01/04/13	03/31/25
Samuel	Hoar	Superior Court Judge	03/26/14	03/31/25
Howard	Kalfus	Superior Court Judge	10/24/11	03/31/25
Elizabeth	Mann	Superior Court Judge	12/28/16	03/31/25
Megan	Shafritz	Superior Court Judge	03/21/18	03/31/25
Timothy	Tomasi	Superior Court Judge	12/15/10	03/31/25

Support FYIVT Today – Choose Your Impact! Name Your Own Price to Help Us Keep Fighting for Truth and Transparency. Every Contribution Makes a Difference!

Public Oversight and Accountability

Vermonters have a direct role in ensuring judicial accountability. If a resident has concerns about a particular judge, they have the right to:

Contact the Judicial Retention Committee – This committee collects public input during judicial retention reviews and makes recommendations to the legislature. The committee’s next meeting is scheduled for February 5 at 4:30 PM and will be available for public viewing via livestream.
Reach out to elected representatives – The Vermont General Assembly, which votes on judicial retention, consists of state legislators who represent the people. Concerned citizens can voice their opinions and encourage their representatives to consider their perspectives when voting on whether to retain a judge.
Get Involved – Attend public meetings, submit feedback to the Judicial Retention Committee, and engage with legislators to ensure accountability in the justice system. Staying informed and participating in these processes strengthens the integrity of Vermont’s legal system.

Additionally, since State’s Attorneys are elected, residents can hold them accountable during elections, ensuring that prosecution policies align with public expectations.

Challenges Facing Vermont’s Justice System

Vermont’s justice system faces several challenges, including:

Bail reform and pretrial releases, which have resulted in repeat offenders cycling through the system.
Underfunded law enforcement and courts, leading to backlogs in criminal cases.
Resource inequities, where rural areas lack adequate staffing for prosecution and alternative rehabilitation programs.

To address these issues, Vermont needs to invest in law enforcement, prosecution, and judicial resources, ensuring that the system functions effectively while balancing rehabilitation and public safety.

Conclusion

Understanding Vermont’s justice system is essential as the state navigates rising crime rates. Vermonters should take an active role in holding both elected prosecutors and appointed judges accountable through the available oversight mechanisms. By engaging with the judicial retention process and advocating for well-resourced law enforcement, citizens can help shape a fair and effective justice system that balances public safety and legal integrity.

Dave Soulia | FYIVT

#fyivt #VermontJustice #JudicialAccountability #CrimeReform

Support Us for as Little as $5 – Get In The Fight!!

Make a Big Impact with $25/month—Become a Premium Supporter!

Join the Top Tier of Supporters with $50/month—Become a SUPER Supporter!