Rutland’s Budget Breakdown: Where Your Tax Dollars Are Going and What It Means for the City’s Future

As Rutland’s mayoral and Board of Aldermen elections approach, residents are facing a crucial question: Is the city’s leadership managing its finances effectively?

A decade-long analysis of Rutland’s budget reveals steady spending growth, particularly in employee salaries, pensions, and retiree healthcare (OPEB). These costs now consume over 30% of the city’s budget, leaving limited room for infrastructure improvements, community programs, and other public services.

With voters heading to the polls, it’s time to examine what’s working, what’s not, and what the future holds if these financial trends continue.

🔹 Successes: What’s Going Right?

1. Budget Growth & Stability

The city’s total budget has increased from $19 million in 2013 to over $26 million in 2023.
This reflects a growing tax base and stable revenues, which is a positive sign compared to cities facing fiscal decline.

2. Public Safety Investment

Police and fire services received $10.3 million in funding in 2023, up from previous years.
The city has prioritized law enforcement and emergency response, ensuring that Rutland remains well-resourced for public safety.

3. Managing Debt Responsibly

Debt service payments have remained relatively low compared to other expense categories.
Unlike financially distressed cities (e.g., Detroit before its bankruptcy), Rutland is not overloaded with debt repayments, keeping its borrowing manageable.

🔸 Challenges: Where the Pressure is Building

1. Salaries, Pensions & OPEB Are Eating the Budget

Employee costs have steadily risen, making up over 32% of the budget in 2023.
Pension contributions alone have doubled over the last decade, now exceeding $3 million annually.
OPEB (retiree healthcare) costs are also increasing, with the city paying over $1.1 million last year—despite having zero pre-funding for these obligations.
Takeaway? The city is paying more each year for past employees, leaving fewer funds for current and future needs.

2. Public Works Funding Stagnates

While employee-related costs rise, public works (roads, infrastructure, stormwater) have seen relatively flat funding.
Residents continue to report issues with aging roads, potholes, and winter maintenance struggles.
If costs for salaries and pensions continue to increase, infrastructure could suffer further cutbacks.

3. Crime & Public Safety Concerns

Despite increased police funding, many residents report rising crime rates, particularly related to drugs and property offenses.
This raises the question: Is the increased spending making a difference?
If voters believe crime is still a major issue, they may demand more accountability from city officials.

🌩️ Storms on the Horizon: What Happens If Nothing Changes?

Rutland isn’t on the verge of bankruptcy, but if current spending trends continue, the city could face financial strain in the next decade. Here’s why:

OPEB liabilities remain unfunded: The city’s $9.3 million retiree healthcare obligation is growing, and without a dedicated fund, future budgets will be squeezed even tighter.
Pension costs are rising: If investment returns decline or more employees retire, Rutland may need to raise taxes or cut services to keep up with pension obligations.
Debt payments could increase: While currently manageable, if Rutland borrows to cover future costs, the debt burden could rise.

Without reforms—such as pre-funding retiree healthcare, adjusting employee contributions, or slowing payroll growth—the city could face difficult financial decisions down the road.

Support FYIVT Today – Choose Your Impact! Name Your Own Price to Help Us Keep Fighting for Truth and Transparency. Every Contribution Makes a Difference!

🏛️ What This Means for the Election

The past few years of budget data paint a mixed picture of Rutland’s leadership.

✅ Positive Marks for the Incumbents:

They’ve maintained a growing budget without taking on excessive debt.
Public safety funding has increased, keeping emergency services strong.
The city has avoided financial crisis despite rising costs.

❌ Concerns & Weaknesses:

Rising crime despite increased police funding raises questions about effectiveness.
Salaries, pensions, and retiree benefits are crowding out other services, limiting spending flexibility.
No action on OPEB pre-funding means future taxpayers will bear an increasing burden.

💭 Voter Takeaway:

If residents believe Rutland is on solid financial ground, they may re-elect the incumbents.
If they feel rising costs are unsustainable and public services are suffering, they may push for new leadership with stronger fiscal oversight.

📢 The Bottom Line

Rutland’s financial picture is stable—for now. But without changes, the city could face tough financial choices in the coming years, including potential tax increases, service cuts, or debt growth.

As voters head to the polls, the key question is:
Are city leaders spending your tax dollars wisely, or are they letting long-term liabilities grow unchecked?

The decision is now in the hands of Rutland’s residents.

Dave Soulia | FYIVT

#fyivt #RutlandVT #TownHallElections #BudgetCrisis

Support Us for as Little as $5 – Get In The Fight!!

Make a Big Impact with $25/month—Become a Premium Supporter!

Join the Top Tier of Supporters with $50/month—Become a SUPER Supporter!