The conversation surrounding climate change has shifted from meaningful debate to rampant fearmongering, with exaggerated claims of impending catastrophe overwhelming rational discourse. This climate of panic isn’t just damaging to public morale; it’s harmful to society’s ability to think clearly and act effectively. When lawmakers and activists constantly push doomsday narratives, they stoke anxiety, discourage engagement, and overshadow the very real progress already being made.
Recent data from a Nature report reveals that while global temperatures continue to rise, there is no evidence of a sudden acceleration in warming that would justify extreme alarm. In fact, since the 1970s, the trend has remained steady, contradicting the dire predictions that many have made. Meanwhile, U.S. greenhouse gas emissions per unit of GDP have dropped by 55% since 1990, a testament to the strides made through technological innovation, economic development, and cleaner energy practices. The Environmental Kuznets Curve (EKC) suggests that as nations become wealthier, they tend to adopt more sustainable practices, indicating that economic growth, rather than sacrifice, is the key to a cleaner future.
Yet, despite the evidence, Vermont’s legislative agenda seems fixated on pushing drastic lifestyle changes for its residents, as if the state’s negligible emissions could significantly alter the trajectory of global climate trends. It’s time to reject this “fear porn” and instead promote policies that support economic growth and innovation—creating a hopeful future that people want to work toward.
A Thousand “Vermonts”
To put Vermont’s greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions into perspective, consider that the entire state emitted approximately 7.99 million metric tons of CO2 equivalent (MMTCO2e) in 2020 (Vermont Outside)(Vermont Legislature). In contrast, the U.S. has achieved a 55% reduction in emissions per unit of GDP from 1990 to 2022, equating to the elimination of GHG emissions equivalent to “a thousand Vermonts.” The scale of this national reduction far surpasses the entire emissions footprint of the state, making Vermont’s impact on global climate trends insignificant.
Despite this reality, Vermont’s legislature continues to push for drastic measures, seemingly believing that the state’s sacrifices will set a leading example. This narrative ignores the data showing that significant national progress has already been achieved without requiring extreme lifestyle changes. Instead of forcing burdensome policies on residents, Vermont could better serve its citizens by embracing growth and economic development, which have proven effective in reducing emissions across wealthier nations.
The Damaging Effects of Fearmongering
“Fear porn” messaging not only distorts the reality of environmental progress but also damages the mental health and outlook of students and the broader public. Young people are being inundated with catastrophic predictions that lead them to believe their future is hopelessly grim. This pervasive fear stifles motivation and creates a culture of anxiety, where the belief in imminent disaster overshadows constructive action. It is a corrosive mindset that saps the optimism and drive necessary for individuals to innovate and pursue real solutions.
The relentless focus on extreme outcomes can also polarize public discourse, making it harder to have rational conversations about practical steps forward. When fear takes center stage, it diminishes the space for balanced, data-driven approaches and can lead to policies that are more about signaling virtue than achieving measurable environmental benefits.
Economic Growth as the Path Forward
Evidence supports that economic growth leads to environmental improvements. The Environmental Kuznets Curve (EKC) hypothesis illustrates how, as societies become wealthier, they tend to reduce pollution and adopt more sustainable practices. This pattern is seen across many advanced economies, including the U.S., where technological advancements, energy efficiency, and a shift to cleaner energy sources have contributed to significant reductions in emissions over the last few decades (US EPA)(Vermont Outside).
Rather than prioritizing restrictive climate policies that may hinder economic development, Vermont’s leaders should focus on enabling economic prosperity. By fostering innovation, reducing regulatory barriers, and encouraging sustainable business practices, the state can achieve both environmental and economic goals. When people are free to pursue growth and creativity, they can develop the technologies and strategies needed to continue reducing emissions effectively.
Vermont’s Role: Leading by Example, but Rationally
While Vermont’s emissions are a fraction of the national total, the state can still play a role in driving positive change by setting a rational example. Instead of pushing policies that prioritize alarmism and immediate sacrifices, Vermont can demonstrate how sustainable economic growth can be achieved alongside environmental stewardship. This approach would resonate more with residents and inspire other states to adopt practical, economically sound policies.
The path forward involves embracing policies that encourage technological innovation, reward energy efficiency, and support economic expansion—all of which naturally lead to cleaner practices as societies become more affluent. Vermont does not need to sacrifice its way of life to make a positive impact; it needs to embrace a vision where economic prosperity and environmental health go hand in hand.
The Historical Parallel: A Lesson from the Little Ice Age
The behavior of Vermont legislators and climate activists today bears a striking resemblance to the reactions of medieval societies at the onset of the Little Ice Age (circa 1300-1850). During that period, harsh and unpredictable weather led to crop failures, famine, and social upheaval. Lacking scientific understanding, people attributed these hardships to supernatural forces or divine punishment, leading to irrational responses like scapegoating and ritualistic practices.
Today, despite a far greater understanding of environmental processes, there is still a tendency to resort to extreme responses based on fear. The persistent climate alarmism echoes the medieval superstition-driven behaviors, where fear overshadowed reason and led to misguided actions. Vermont’s legislative response seems to mirror this historical pattern, pushing for drastic measures based on exaggerated threats rather than data-driven approaches that consider existing progress.
Just as societies eventually moved beyond medieval superstitions, Vermont’s leaders must move beyond alarmism and adopt policies grounded in innovation and practical solutions. Embracing economic growth as a tool for sustainability offers a path forward that prioritizes rational action over fear-driven responses.
A Hopeful Future Worth Working Toward
It’s time to push back against the culture of fear and embrace a more hopeful, balanced view of what lies ahead. The data is clear: the U.S. has made meaningful progress in reducing greenhouse gas emissions, and with continued growth, even more can be achieved. Let’s inspire future generations not with fear, but with the promise of a sustainable and prosperous world—one that they can help build through innovation, hard work, and optimism.
Vermont’s leaders must recognize that alarmism is not a strategy for success. Real progress comes from fostering economic opportunities that empower people to create the solutions of tomorrow. If we shift the focus from fear to hope, we can cultivate a future where environmental stewardship and economic growth are not in conflict but are complementary goals. This balanced approach offers a way forward that inspires action, not through fear, but through a realistic and hopeful vision of what can be achieved when growth and sustainability are pursued together.
Dave Soulia | FYIVT
You can find FYIVT on YouTube | X(Twitter) | Facebook | Parler (@fyivt) | Gab | Instagram
#fyivt #fearporn #climatealarmism #economicgrowth
Support Us for as Little as $5 – Get In The Fight!!
Make a Big Impact with $25/month—Become a Premium Supporter!
Join the Top Tier of Supporters with $50/month—Become a SUPER Supporter!
Leave a Reply